Direct Mail Mastery: Why is your Direct Mail campaign not working

12/15/2023 by Justin

Direct Mail Mastery: Why is your Direct Mail campaign not working

In the realm of real estate marketing, direct mail has stood the test of time as a powerful tool for connecting with prospects and generating leads. At Open Letter Marketing, we’ve embraced this traditional yet effective approach, particularly through the innovative strategies of Justin Silverio, founder of JS2 Homes and Open Letter Marketing. We’ll explore how consistent use of direct mail can transform your real estate business into a deal flow machine.

Open Letter Marketing’s Approach:

Our approach to direct mail in real estate is grounded in understanding the audience and crafting messages that resonate. We emphasize the importance of less competitive but more personal direct mail strategies over purely digital methods. This approach is not just about sending letters but crafting a strategy that includes who to mail, when to mail, and what to mail, thus adding real value to the marketing efforts. Here are strategies on how to write effective (BLOG LINK MISSING)

Frequency of Mail:

The key to success in direct mail marketing lies in CONSISTENCY. It’s not enough to send out a one-time mailer; building brand awareness and establishing relationships with property owners requires a systematic approach. A multi-touch campaign, where messages are sent at various intervals, is essential for making a lasting impression.

Here’s why:

  • Building Recognition and Trust: People are more likely to engage with a brand or individual they recognize and trust. Regular mailings help people recognize and trust your brand.
  • Timing and Relevance: A recipient might not be interested in selling or buying property when they receive the first mailer. However, as their circumstances change, repeated mailings ensure that your brand is top-of-mind when they are ready to make a decision.
  • Enhancing the Effectiveness of Your Message: Each mailing provides an opportunity to refine and reinforce your message. It’s rare for a single mailer to convey all the nuances of what you offer. Multiple mailings let you refine and strengthen your message over time.
  • Stand Out in the Crowd: In a crowded market, a one-time mailer can easily be lost among numerous other marketing messages. Frequent mailing helps your message stand out and be remembered amidst the competition.
  • Creating a Narrative: Regular mailings allow you to build an engaging narrative about your brand or services. This storytelling approach can be more engaging than a one-off advertisement, as it develops a deeper connection with the audience.
  • Higher Response Chances: Marketing studies have shown that repeated exposure increases the likelihood of a response. More mailings increase the likelihood of getting a response.
  • Feedback and Adaptation: Regular mailing provides ongoing feedback about what works and what doesn’t. This enables you to adapt and tailor future mailings based on the responses and engagement levels of previous ones.
  • Combating Digital Fatigue: In an increasingly digital world, where email inboxes are often overflowing, direct mail offers a tangible and less cluttered alternative. Regular mail stands out and can be a refreshing change for recipients, making them more likely to engage with it.

Best Practices:

  • Targeted Messaging: Understand your audience and segment your mailing list to ensure that your message reaches the right people.
  • Visual Appeal: Use concise and eye-catching design elements, like those in real estate postcards, which don’t require the recipient to open an envelope, making your message immediately visible.
  • Personalization: Implement strategies like handwritten letters or custom-designed postcards to add a personal touch.

Direct mail, when used consistently and strategically, can be a game-changer for real estate investors. You can effectively turn prospects into leads and establish meaningful connections. Remember, the success of your direct mail campaign hinges on your ability to connect with your audience on a personal level while standing out in their mailbox.

Get a no-obligation call with one of our campaign managers!

You May Also Like...


With social media, email newsletters and other online marketing tools, you may think old-fashioned direct mail is dead. However, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Direct mail campaigns are just as relevant today...

Why You Should Still Use Direct Marketing in the Digital Age

If you are a real estate investor looking for leads, you already know how important direct mail marketing is. But what can you do to ensure your real estate postcards convert as best as possible?

What Makes An Attractive Real Estate Postcard?

2020 was an unprecedented year. Unfortunately, many of the problems of last year haven’t magically disappeared for 2021. You may wonder if you should continue your direct mail marketing efforts this year. Real estate...

Continue Your Real Estate Direct Mail Marketing into 2021